so ..... who,s the boss now?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
23 Aug 2010 8:08pm
The Orgill report concluded that the complaint rate of the BER was 2.7%. That is not "A RORT" .
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
23 Aug 2010 9:00pm
Gestalt said...

frant said...

I think its time for everyone to take a deep breath and stand back...... your team did not win!!!!
The people have spoken and our future is now in the hands of the three independents and they will determine the outcome. No amount of we won this or they lost that is going to change the fact that neither side won.


our future isn't in the hands of 3 independants. that's why we have a senate. we are probably in a better position now than we were before the elections.

finally the major parties will take the environment serious, finally we will have real debate about the issues and hopefully we will eventually have 3 parties in the lower house.

now that's democratic.

Gestalt I read your posts and you made 2 references to GW and the environment. You said "finally the major parties will take the environment seriously" I would say global warming policy is a serious part of environment policy, wouldn't you ? And your mob reneged on an bi-partisan agreement made with Rudd and installed Abbott. Abbott led the coalition and defeated the Bill. The Bill therefore could not pass. You said " This was their(labor's) biggest broken promise ( climate change)". This is not a broken promise. Your lot let every body down, right there, we could have proceeded in a bi partisan way to improve the system but instead you left us to carry the can. Now climate change is an issue stuck in a never never land. Labor and the greens support action and the conservatives are undermining and shilly shallying. Disgraceful, and Gestalt you voted for them. One last thing, you said"Labor got it's ass kicked. suck it up. democracy won" for once you are absolutely right. We got our ass kicked and yes democracy always wins
SandS
SandS
VIC
5904 posts
VIC, 5904 posts
23 Aug 2010 10:18pm
poor relative said...

My wife is still the boss.


yep ,and the sooner we all understand that, she who must be obeyed ,will eventually be obeyed. the better off we all will be
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14969 posts
QLD, 14969 posts
23 Aug 2010 11:19pm
@logman,

the orgill report is still not finalised and a coronial inquest is being tabled. other than the critisism it has received from nsw greens and coalition it did not have the powers required to fully explore the outcomes. it is worth noting that the 2.7% figure is the figure based on complaints orgill looking into. there are accusations that some complaints weren't accepted. time will tell what the actual outcomes were

as to your post above. yes, finally the major parties will take the environment seriously is what i said. i hardly see that as saying the libs have a credible policy. it also says i think the same of labor. so what's your point. other than to think i share the same view on climate change as the coalition. as i pointed out. i don't vote for a party. i vote for policy and i certainly don't share either labors or libs view on climate change

and again, what do you mean my mob? more of the preconceived ideas. i have voted labor, liberal, national and the greens before at different times and at different levels of government because i vote for who i believe has the best policies and can do the job. yes i do research the policies prior to making my decisions. one of the main items stopping me voting greens this election was the fact they joined forces with labor. that to me was a deal breaker. but as you suggest, i pretty much don't vote labor federally because of unionism and track record. if they change, i'll change.

so don't lump me in with any particular party. i'm no sheep.

as for your comments on the ets. what your are saying is basically the labor party line. labor tried twice to get their ets policy through the senate. they failed both times by not gaining support from the greens or the independants. they failed to broker the deal. they failed to broker a lot of deals considering they had so many numbers in both houses, funny that. they also didn't need the support of the libs to get it through by the way. as it stood everyone in the senate pretty much voted against it including the libs, indipendants and greens.

furthermore, labor could have then also asked for a double dissolution election if they felt strongly enough about it but they didn't did they. they rolled over.

some of the facts en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_Pollution_Reduction_Scheme

now back on topic.

as far as a minority governments go, (regardless of who that is) it can have some very positive outcomes becuase you can end up with a very balanced legislative process. anyone can introduce a bill into the lower house, both from the opposition and government. there it is debated and voted on. if you have a majority rule in the lower house then typically only the views of the majority party will get through to the upper house. but in the case of a few independants or greens forming the balance of power bills can get through that are not necessarily the view of the minority government if members cross the floor

i don't beleive climate change is stuck in never never land.

the indepandants so far have said they want green power industries, national broadband, carbon emissions scheme certainty and no mining tax to name a few.

the greens also now have a lower house representative to introduce bills.

if someone does manage to form a government it will be an interesting 3 years.





log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
24 Aug 2010 10:04am
Labor had the numbers in the reps but needed 7 senators in the upper house to vote to get the ETS in . Your mob reneged on the agreement organised by Turnbull,Macdonald on the Lib side and Wong and Rudd on Labor to pass the bill through the senate. This left Labor trying to convince the greens, but they wanted a different system. The end result , no way to get the bill through the senate. OK that's the history and my point is this: It is just plain deceptive of the Libs to support the bill then pull the rug out from under us at the senate vote , then accuse us of having no global warming policy. And what does this mean into the future? We now have the labor party, burned by the ets legislation trying again to get it up, only now we have an overtly hostile party, run by deniers determined to never let it pass. We had our chance and we blew it. This issue required bi partisan support but now Its gone for the next 20 years. Your Liberal party at work
Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5126 posts
VIC, 5126 posts
24 Aug 2010 11:10am
Gestalt said...

@ gorgo

well if the rest of the states stayed at home then the conservatives would of got into power so i guess the system does work.

you are saying that the people voted, the result was 50/50 but someone should get a majority because some of the states are labor. it makes very liitle sense and not democratic. regardless of distribution of results the result is that it's 50/50.

and on your last point. rather than blame the voters of QLD and WA how about you level the result at the feet of the politicians.

or those that did donkey votes, or the preferential system or whatever. it doesn't matter in the end.
...


I'm not saying any of those things. I'm simply pointing out the obvious inconsistency in the distribution of the numbers.

For whatever the reason the voters in QLD are really really pissed off at something to do with the ALP.
Bigwavedave
Bigwavedave
QLD
2057 posts
QLD, 2057 posts
24 Aug 2010 11:24pm
SomeOtherGuy said...

At the risk of injecting some facts into this thread - from the AEC's website as of now:

House of Reps Two Party Preferred results:
Australian Labor Party 5,060,285
Liberal/National Coalition 4,929,004

Historically, it wouldn't be the first time a party got the majority of votes but didn't win office. And the seat count could go 73/73. I don't see how any side can claim a victory, or that the "other side" lost.


But there isn't two parties and no amount of creative accounting will get labor the majority. The Green vote was not a Labor vote.

Labor received 38% of the vote
Coalition 44%
Greens 11.5%
Other 6.5%

The people have spoken. Form a government of all the elected representatives and get the job done without all the adversarial bullsh1t.

Democracy is about representing the people not an idealogical party.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7298 posts
WA, 7298 posts
24 Aug 2010 9:50pm
I am sure Tony Danza was the boss, or atleast that was the premise of the comedy anyway.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7298 posts
WA, 7298 posts
24 Aug 2010 9:54pm
I voted for the illuminati and the NWOONWO for the senate.

Yet - nowhere in any of the ballot counting or posted results did either get even one vote.

Clearly something very very nefarious going on.

nick0
nick0
NSW
510 posts
NSW, 510 posts
25 Aug 2010 9:12pm
20c on MR ABBOT
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
26 Aug 2010 1:12am
New election please, the thought of being ruled by 3 politicians too crazy even for the National party makes my blood run cold
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply