Stkilda Problem?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
robecq
robecq
VIC
51 posts
VIC, 51 posts
21 Mar 2006 11:51pm
I spoke to a pole surfer who sails just north of the stkilda kiters today, and he had a complaint about kiters losing there boards and letting them drift down wind into the sailboard aera. Apperently a few sailboards have been badly damaged from hitting these kiteboards that are off on their own and hard to see. I'm guessing the kiters are newbies who are having trouble bodydragging back to their board and go in to the beach instead and then collect the board from the water. Any ideas on how to prevent this? is/should the kiter be liable for any damage? obliviously some sort of 3rd party insurance would be good, but do newbies bother (or even know about insurance available)?
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:53am
quote:
Originally posted by robecq

I spoke to a pole surfer who sails just north of the stkilda kiters today, and he had a complaint about kiters losing there boards and letting them drift down wind into the sailboard aera. Apperently a few sailboards have been badly damaged from hitting these kiteboards that are off on their own and hard to see. I'm guessing the kiters are newbies who are having trouble bodydragging back to their board and go in to the beach instead and then collect the board from the water. Any ideas on how to prevent this? is/should the kiter be liable for any damage? obliviously some sort of 3rd party insurance would be good, but do newbies bother (or even know about insurance available)?



The only way is the board leash.
Helemt and board leash (especially for beginners).
Aftewr all these years, I still have and use it, and I've never got hit by the board.
If I am falling and getting off my board, it is very easy to retreive it.
Gee, I think I am starting to bee too repetitive.
I am getting old!
Ben De Jonge
Ben De Jonge
WA
819 posts
WA, 819 posts
22 Mar 2006 9:48am
Please, please, PLEASE!!!! do not start the leash debate again, we have been over and over this and the majority rule is clear - Leashes are 'kin stooooooooopid, and you almost never see them anymore for the clear and simple reason that they can fling your board back at you and puncture body parts.
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:54pm
quote:
Originally posted by Ben De Jonge

Please, please, PLEASE!!!! do not start the leash debate again, we have been over and over this and the majority rule is clear - Leashes are 'kin stooooooooopid, and you almost never see them anymore for the clear and simple reason that they can fling your board back at you and puncture body parts.



Ben,

I agree 100% with you, when you are talking about profficient kitesurfers, knowing, and willing, to bodysurf to rettrive a lost board.
I am talking about learners, which may benefit of having the board on leash.
But, if all of you out there consider leash is not good...
OK, I will shut-up.
ran
ran
VIC
333 posts
ran ran
VIC, 333 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:55pm
quote:
Originally posted by robecq

I spoke to a pole surfer who sails just north of the stkilda kiters today, and he had a complaint about kiters losing there boards and letting them drift down wind into the sailboard aera. Apperently a few sailboards have been badly damaged from hitting these kiteboards that are off on their own and hard to see. I'm guessing the kiters are newbies who are having trouble bodydragging back to their board and go in to the beach instead and then collect the board from the water. Any ideas on how to prevent this? is/should the kiter be liable for any damage? obliviously some sort of 3rd party insurance would be good, but do newbies bother (or even know about insurance available)?



serious, they are complaining about people loosing thier boards? And they hit them and hurt themselves... sorry thats kinda crap. i windsurfed in melb for 10 years and unless you close your eyes while doing it you can see a board in the water, Sure **** happens, but bitching about it? really. No one should ever use a leash, and everyone looses a board at times. Liable? great lets start that up, maybe the rider needs to look where they are going, and why not grab that board and drop it onto the beach, a little bit of help, team work etc.. anyway. JMO
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
22 Mar 2006 10:07am
Silviu,

Learners can learn to bodydrag upwind in about 15 minutes, 30 maximum with proper instruction from a qualified school or instructor. There is no reason on earth anyone should resort to a board leash, unless lazy, crazy or as Ben says, stoopid.

Please do not be encouraging learners to use leashes. There are tips on my website for those that do not know how to body drag upwind. And for your own safety, lose the leash and learn to body drag upwind! Lets hope this thread dies out quickly, it's been done.

Good winds,



silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
22 Mar 2006 1:15pm
OK guys, give up. (Ouups, I said this!!!)
I am going not to be "lazy" anymore!
Ben De Jonge
Ben De Jonge
WA
819 posts
WA, 819 posts
22 Mar 2006 10:59am
I can't believe this, logic and intelligence seem to be winning the day!

I am now considering renouncing my cynicism.

Cheers Darren.

And ran - you are spot on mate, what a crazy thing to complain about. They should be complaining about being stuck in a dud sport, I could understand that.

RAL INN
RAL INN
SA
2898 posts
SA, 2898 posts
22 Mar 2006 1:32pm
Answer to the original ?

The board being adrift is mainly due to the kiter electing to not bodydrag to retrieve it.

I will not let a student have a board until they can demonstrate the ability to bodydrag to retrieve it. I don't want my kit lost.

So assuming they have had lessons and been taught the nessesary skills then it is their choice to leave board.

So it is also their responsibility to cover damages it causes.

and windsurfers coming over a wave at speed don't have much chance of avoiding losing a $200 fin on awell camoflaged kiteboard.
skidsy
skidsy
VIC
31 posts
VIC, 31 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:01pm
St Kilda is a pretty small area to accomodate all these sports.

With massive numbers picking up the sport every summer, mainly ex winsurfers, the Beach and marina can not continue to handle the growth of the sport.

I know that it's good advertising to have all the kite schools and kites at St kilda beach but maybe the learners have to learn somewhere else or make rules to manage the numbers.

It's a sh!ght spot to learn anyway. You spend all you time worrying about the congestion and you dont have much room for error.

Maybe we need to look at the problem at many levels but this sport is to good and there's only a limited ammount of space on the water.
Boris
Boris
261 posts
261 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:12pm
I wear a leash on each leg.
Does that matter?
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:16pm
quote:
Originally posted by Boris

I wear a leash on each leg.
Does that matter?




Of course it does Boris... the authorities fitted them for a good reason. Now, back in your box!
Boris
Boris
261 posts
261 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:17pm
But the gimp's not sleepy yet!
ran
ran
VIC
333 posts
ran ran
VIC, 333 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:19pm
"St Kilda is a pretty small area to accomodate all these sports.

With massive numbers picking up the sport every summer, mainly ex winsurfers, the Beach and marina can not continue to handle the growth of the sport.

I know that it's good advertising to have all the kite schools and kites at St kilda beach but maybe the learners have to learn somewhere else or make rules to manage the numbers.

It's a sh!ght spot to learn anyway. You spend all you time worrying about the congestion and you dont have much room for error.

Maybe we need to look at the problem at many levels but this sport is to good and there's only a limited ammount of space on the water."


where are the best places to kite in Melb? It looks like i will be moving back to my home city later in the year, i think im spoiled with massive downwinders and warm weather (sunshinecoast) and am worried that Melb will suck, pls tell me you guys have great spots and a great local crew, and have space for a Ex-Melbournite moving back in your posse.....
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:27pm
Hey Ran,

If for kitesurfing, I would not come back to Melbourne, not now: the winter's comming, with gusty, deceiving northerly winds, short days and freezing water (by August the average water temperature in the bay drops to 8 - 10 degrees). However, from the point of view of the crew... you can't expect better!!
Looking forward to see you here.
skidsy
skidsy
VIC
31 posts
VIC, 31 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:34pm
Yeah come back to Melbourne. Kite at St Kilda or Brighton on days below 22 degrees. They're a bit soft up there and I dont know if they've heard of a steamer.

Maybe they have but I'd get them to clarify their version.

You can kite you just have to be willing to put in the effort. Rye and Rosebud are the places to be during those cold dreary northerly days
NJPornstar
NJPornstar
WA
790 posts
WA, 790 posts
22 Mar 2006 12:38pm
I've gone back to using a leash.
In f&$%n huge waves rocky beach, its a must.
Sometimes in heavy sets not even spiderman could get the board back.
RAL INN
RAL INN
SA
2898 posts
SA, 2898 posts
22 Mar 2006 4:06pm
Here's a leash idea.

reel type leash with a mini sea anchor that tucks into reel.

then when board heads off on deploying leash and then starts its bungy recoil, the sea anchor slows the recoil.
skidsy
skidsy
VIC
31 posts
VIC, 31 posts
22 Mar 2006 4:48pm
great idea with the anchor dude......
Mr Plow
Mr Plow
VIC
428 posts
VIC, 428 posts
22 Mar 2006 5:18pm
Ditch the board altogether - unhook - and barefoot waterski
skidsy
skidsy
VIC
31 posts
VIC, 31 posts
22 Mar 2006 6:05pm
Or you could use a canoe?
I know skidsy
I know skidsy
VIC
19 posts
VIC, 19 posts
22 Mar 2006 9:38pm
Or you could attach your board to a white bonds singlet.
I know skidsy
I know skidsy
VIC
19 posts
VIC, 19 posts
22 Mar 2006 9:50pm
quote:
Originally posted by skidsy

Yeah come back to Melbourne. Kite at St Kilda or Brighton on days below 22 degrees. They're a bit soft up there and I dont know if they've heard of a steamer.

Maybe they have but I'd get them to clarify their version.

You can kite you just have to be willing to put in the effort. Rye and Rosebud are the places to be during those cold dreary northerly days



Hey I don't kite anywhere south of Brighton. My chest plate, bright red peanut helmet, and footy jumper keeps me warm all year round. Followed by a few sauvignon blanc's to warm me up at the George. You guys don't know what your missing out on.
P.S. Bundy and turbo-shandies are for the evil.
I know skidsy
I know skidsy
VIC
19 posts
VIC, 19 posts
22 Mar 2006 10:16pm
A way to reduce the numbers is easy. I have been kiting at Caroline Springs, and Craigieburn, and for holidays Pankenham Springs. Its great there is not many kiters, wind direction doesn't matter, close to the shops. I wouldn't kite anywhere else.

I have got one word for you DELFIN
Soonee
Soonee
VIC
147 posts
VIC, 147 posts
24 Mar 2006 9:23pm
Leashes mmmm where do you start with thias conundrum?
My 2 cents is that they are not really a problem...if..
a. you have it set for a really big ankle, you can slip out really easily in case of imminent disaster

b. you are not jumping.



Newbies sholud have em, but stay safe in what they are up to
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
24 Mar 2006 8:22pm
quote:
Originally posted by Soonee

Leashes mmmm where do you start with thias conundrum?
My 2 cents is that they are not really a problem...if..
a. you have it set for a really big ankle, you can slip out really easily in case of imminent disaster

b. you are not jumping.



Newbies sholud have em, but stay safe in what they are up to



[C] WEAR A HELMET! When using a leash.
Soonee
Soonee
VIC
147 posts
VIC, 147 posts
25 Mar 2006 9:41am
[C] WEAR A HELMET! When using a leash.

Of course wear a helmet.

I expect they will bcome compulsory sometime soon a bureaucracy seeks to reduce mans ability to think for himself.

Or Azza an even better idea. All boards should be banned. Then we wouldn't have a problem. You wouldn't need a helmet or a leash and then there will be no losrt boards, nothing to argue on this page.

Everyone's happy!!![}:)]

BOOMAN
BOOMAN
VIC
333 posts
VIC, 333 posts
25 Mar 2006 6:11pm
im pretty new and am about to buy a leash cos i keep loosing my board and it takes me 5-20 minutes to retrieve it sometimes, im just cracking the up wind barrier but sometimes i just cant reach it, also wtf is it dangerous if im not jumping out the water and its an ultra lond surfboard leash....... 20 minutes for #$%@#% sake
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
25 Mar 2006 6:44pm
quote:
Originally posted by BOOMAN

im pretty new and am about to buy a leash cos i keep loosing my board and it takes me 5-20 minutes to retrieve it sometimes, im just cracking the up wind barrier but sometimes i just cant reach it, also wtf is it dangerous if im not jumping out the water and its an ultra lond surfboard leash....... 20 minutes for #$%@#% sake



GOODman!
kiterpilot
kiterpilot
WA
249 posts
WA, 249 posts
25 Mar 2006 5:59pm
this leash topic has been done to death... BLOODY LEARN TO BODY DRAG FELLAS !. Takes 30 minutes out of your weekly water time...

And dont give me some sheit that the topic is not about body draggin, it's about lost boards and poley's hitting them. It has every thing to do with body draggin as if you can do it you wouldnt lose your board

Here's an idea, why not pass the hat around and ask your local kite school if they would put on a lesson/demo for all you guys that MUST learn to body drag and self rescue your selves...
doppelganger
doppelganger
VIC
337 posts
VIC, 337 posts
25 Mar 2006 9:34pm
I am also going through the learning process and currently don't use a board leash, but I'm considering it at the moment.
I’ve been looking at the basic Pros and Cons and thinking I may use a leash in certain situations, with a back up safety.

The pros speak for themselves: more time boarding, less time body dragging.

The Cons: Board could rebound back, hitting you and causing injury, death.
The board could become a sea anchor.

All the talk about the dangers of using a leash comes down to one main thing, the load on the leash. In one of the past threads in relation to leashes, someone suggested using electrical cable ties as a load release measure and I'm thinking of trying this out.
Get some cable ties, attach a few to a ring on your harness and then attach the leash to one of the cable ties. If you have a mild mishap and the board comes off, it’s nearby. If everything’s going pear shaped and ya having the mother of all wipe outs, the cable tie breaks under the load, you body drag back to the board and clip the leash to one of the other cable ties.

If any one is using (have used) this method, what brand (size) cable ties do you use?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply