Stkilda Problem?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
bondo
bondo
QLD
699 posts
QLD, 699 posts
25 Mar 2006 8:56pm
was just speaking to a mate of mine on this topic (leashes), his comment was if you cant self rescue, self launch, self land and body drag back to your board then you shouldnt be on the water. I agree. either practice it yourself, go back and get some more lessons, or stay at home. after the latest accident the last thing we need is some leash wearing kook getting smashed in the face by their board and having to get rescued and taken to hospital.
kiterpilot
kiterpilot
WA
249 posts
WA, 249 posts
25 Mar 2006 8:15pm
here here bondo... body dragging should be one of the first things you learn with or without an instructor. riders that dont learn the basics these days go a long way to causing problems between codes.
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
25 Mar 2006 9:52pm
quote:
Originally posted by ran
i am worried that Melb will suck,


I got news for u ran .........
Melb sucked long before they invented kiting
Now it sucks with teeth out & fully pouted lips
(sorta like a breath of fresh Paulios nan )

Go West young man - to the blessed land of opportunity
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
25 Mar 2006 10:55pm
those of you that still think board leashes are safe or can't see the point or don't understand the dangers please use the search and do some reading

Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
25 Mar 2006 11:54pm
Hi Octane,

Jumping is the least of your worries. Any high speed crash where you are seperated from your board and dragged by the kite will be an opportunity to cop a board in the back of the head or in the neck.

A quick release is nice in theory, but if you are being stretched by the kite pulling your top half and the board pulling the bottom half as it tombstones, you definately will not be able to reach down to your pulled ankle to get the QR even if you have the time.

I don't understand people that wear leashes. It is so easy to learn to body drag upwind. Most of the girls and guys we teach take about 10 minutes to learn this essential skill. But hey, you should really save that few dollars it'll cost for a lesson so that you can afford a new board when your leash snaps and you don't know how to get back to it in strong winds.

Either that or put the money towards a motorised wheel chair when your spinal cord is smashed by the nose of the board into the back of your neck, hell, I hear wheel chairs are really extreme and more fun than kiting anyways, look at it this way, you're on your way. Walking, running, sex, wiping your own bum and feeding yourself are all highly overated anyway.

You are entitled to make your own decision in the end, even if it's a stupid one!


Good winds,



doppelganger
doppelganger
VIC
337 posts
VIC, 337 posts
26 Mar 2006 3:44am
I posted earlier on about the cable tie idea someone had mentioned in an a past post.
I would not use a standard board leash for risk of injury.The leash has to have flex to account for the load which may be put on the board,which,with no flex,could break your ankle and because it has flex,it results in a recoil.From my reading on the subject,it's this recoil that can cause injury,and even death.
Having stated the above,if you used a leash with a ie:cable tie,that would snap under modest presure,you could use a leash with less flex,resulting in less recoil.

If I'm missing something,can someone please explain.I'm not talking about the standard leash set up.I can body drag upwind to retrieve my board almost all of the time ,but,I've only got up on the board recently and at times at some locations,due to tide ect,would rather utilize the time on the board.

What might be some of the pitfalls in this concept that I may be over looking?
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
26 Mar 2006 1:57am
you become airbourne with the board on your feet, be it from an intentional jump or from a nasty gust/loft

whilst airbourne, the board comes off your feet and lags behind you slightly. the leash does not get loaded but manages to keep the board roughly on your trajectory

you hit the water and stop.

the board cleans you up.

kiterpilot
kiterpilot
WA
249 posts
WA, 249 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:39am
People, please please take the advice from those of us that have been riding for what seems like for ever...

Kitehard speaks the truth, back in the early days I have had the board tombstoning behind me while being super powered up and it's a scary position to be in, only happend once !

All the guys on here that will never defend or advocate the use of a leash on your board are not saying it because it looks cool, it's just bloody stupid. You guys that use them are a statistic just waiting to happen, a statistic just to get the sport a bad name, a statistic just to get beaches closed.

I couldnt give a phuk if you get the board in the back of your head and become a cripple or better die. I give a phuk when some dumb ass twat comes on here and starts a thread asking for charity for Joe Schmo's family because Joe was a top bloke but was killed the other day by his board hitting him in the head cause he had a board leash.

Notice how none of the board companies advocate the use or sell board leashes ?

Oh and when your sitting in your wheel chair, I'll be the one on the water...
NSW, 4382 posts
26 Mar 2006 4:47pm
Which beaches closed because of board leashes.???
Where are the dead people because of board leashes???
Where are the loads of people in wheelchairs from leash caused injuries???
Talk about a load of drivel.

Begginers can make good use of a board leash - provided they fit a weak link to it, stop the BS!

We have seen heaps of begginers progress sooner because they are not phaffing around trying to get back to the board all the time, often spending more than 50-80% of a session trying to get their board or losing it!!!

Whats so complicated about wearing the appropriate protective gear, and then tying a piece of 100 - 150 lb dacron line between the board and the leash??

I agree that once a person is beyond getting on the board and riding upwind, they should ditch the leash, most of the time. If the winds are light and body dragging is marginal the leash is needed, same with tides and currents. Same with people who just cruise. Not recommended in waves at all.

Straight out closed minded no, no no is just silly, remember what it was like to learn???

We never recommend stretchy surfboard straight or coiled leashes though, only the webbing type reel leashes, fitted with a weak link.
http://www.kitepower.com.au/catalog/product_16636_NSI_Improved_Reel_Leash_cat_275.html

Think of it like a fuse in an electrical circuit, sure electricity can kill you, no reason to ban it though.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve McCormack
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
26 Mar 2006 2:44pm
Hey Steve,

The wheelchair thing is a worse case scenario, one which I hope to never witness or read about. Helmets and impact vests do not protect you from a hit in the back of the neck just above the shoulders. A serious hit here could in fact crush your spinal chord leaving you Quad.

The list of persons having stitches from flying boards is long and prestigious. You may recall a certain postie was almost killed in Botany Bay due to a leash by landing on his board and the surf style fins cutting deep into his inner thigh missing his femoral artery by a 1/4 inch. He would have bled to death long before making it to the beach.

There is no need for leashes. As a kiteshop that sell reel leashes, I respect your right to defend their use with a suitable "fused" link, and accept that the danger is significantly reduced but not eliminated. However, I reserve my right to champion an even safer approach - NO Leash.

I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one.


Good winds to all,


gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
26 Mar 2006 3:10pm
For someone who used to wear a leash and was stupid.....at the end of the day, I would have to agree with KH.

I still carry my retractable leash for emergencies.........bad crashes where I have to focus 100% on relaunching the kite, or to attach other objects (kites, boards, and even people) in rescue attempts.

It is a useful accessory, but not for beninners....that's for sure! If you don't want to loose your board, super-glue your feet to it.
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
26 Mar 2006 7:51pm
I promised not to get anymore involved in this debate, however….
Wearing a leash should be a personal choice, according with personal experience, style of kitesurfing and a lot of other considerations.
I, personally, wear both kite and board leash, I find both of them very useful.
I am cruising, often very far in the bay (5 - 7 Km away) so it is very important for me to be able to retrieve the board in seconds and get moving again.
In 6 years of kitesurfing, I never got heat by the board, as in most occasions when I get off the board, I de-power the kite instantly, and the drag was minimal.
Another think is where the leash is attached to the board
Most of the cases the leash is attached to the handle, which is in the middle of the board and this attachment point makes the board to dive or stand up in the water, making it an "anchor", and when it releases from the water, may act as a projectile!!
However if the leash is attached as close as possible to one of the tips of the board, than the board will just follow the boarder.
When jumping, this is a totally different case, I totally agree that a leash may cause some upsets, especially that most of the "jumpers" will not go too far form the beach (what's the point to jump mate, if nobody can see you?!
Now I promise I will not get involved anymore in this debate!!!
However remember, in some car accidents, the car bursts in flame, and it was found that the seatbelt was delaying the occupants to leave the car in time , and they got burned, sometimes to death.
We still wear seatbelts, don’t we?
Mr Plow
Mr Plow
VIC
428 posts
VIC, 428 posts
26 Mar 2006 8:49pm
If you kite 5-7km out then you had better be a damn good swimmer.

That is possibly the most dumb, irresponsible move I have heard of.

Where is your support? What happens if your leading edge deflates/pops?

Yet another hero giving kiting a great rap....seriously mate - its not impressive, just mid numbingly stupid.
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
26 Mar 2006 9:30pm
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Plow

If you kite 5-7km out then you had better be a damn good swimmer.

That is possibly the most dumb, irresponsible move I have heard of.

Where is your support? What happens if your leading edge deflates/pops?

Yet another hero giving kiting a great rap....seriously mate - its not impressive, just mid numbingly stupid.


Mr Plow

I am kitesurfing ALWAYS with:
GPS.
Mobile phone.
Someone knows always where I am going, and when I do expect to come back
If possible in pair with somone else
And don't forget, I am doing this only in the Port Phillip Bay, so, if I cant go back... I always get to a safe shore from where I can be picked up.
Before going to the beach:
Check the latest forcast on Bureau of Meteorology website.
Check the Bay wind Website.
Check the sky!
I wear always:
Helmet
Long wetsuit
PFD/impact vest
Booties
Generaly:
Never jump near the beach
Keep a safe distance from stupids
I rather go 100 m downwind to land my kite, than to land it on a crowded beach
I am a good friend of the Life Saving Club
never kite on a beach I don't know, unless I am getting some advice from the locals.
And the list is longer and longer.
And by the way, yes I am a bloddy good swimmer, and I know very well most of the self rescue techniques.
So before judging, and insulting, get all the facts!!!
NSW, 4382 posts
26 Mar 2006 9:44pm
quote:
Originally posted by Kitehard

Hey Steve,

The wheelchair thing is a worse case scenario, one which I hope to never witness or read about. Helmets and impact vests do not protect you from a hit in the back of the neck just above the shoulders. A serious hit here could in fact crush your spinal chord leaving you Quad.

The list of persons having stitches from flying boards is long and prestigious. You may recall a certain postie was almost killed in Botany Bay due to a leash by landing on his board and the surf style fins cutting deep into his inner thigh missing his femoral artery by a 1/4 inch. He would have bled to death long before making it to the beach.

There is no need for leashes. As a kiteshop that sell reel leashes, I respect your right to defend their use with a suitable "fused" link, and accept that the danger is significantly reduced but not eliminated. However, I reserve my right to champion an even safer approach - NO Leash.

I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one.


Good winds to all,






G'day Darren

Read my post again, because there are points made that agree with you and others here, an some others that do not.
Blanket NO rules about leashes don't take into account a persons own awareness of the dangers, their precautions, their right to assess the risk and still choose to use one, etc.

As stated there are very legitimate reasons to use a leash, even for begginers, mainly because it speeds up the learning curve, and lessens their time of dependence on one. Leashes should always be sold with cautions, and a weak link fitted.

Can you recall or quote a single instance of a person being made a quad by a leash, any type of leash?

That postie is still hammering himself, without a leash, he landed on a board again last week and broke it, some people are always more likely to be injured. Given that he does kite a lot, he has not been injured often, and he does go hard!

Everyone should be taught or learn to bodydrag upwind no argument, but begginers are always going out underpowered, and are unable to drag upwind. So many boards get lost due to this silly insistance about leashes.

If you are an intermediate to advanced kiter doing rotations and unhooked stuff, then that would be crazy, but the majority of riders are cruisers, are mature adults who can assess the risks, take precautions and have the right to maximise their enjoyment.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve McCormack
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
26 Mar 2006 9:45pm
And one more think: I will rather loose 30 minutes from my kitesurfing time to help a beginner get safe (or out of trouble) than to seat and look (and laugh) how he will get hurt!!!
robecq
robecq
VIC
51 posts
VIC, 51 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:49pm
I'm almost sorry I started this thread, It was NOT meant to be a he said she said thread about f'ing leashes. The problem IS that people are losing their boards because they have chosen not to use a leash (fair enough) and can't or wont bodydrag upwind (not good enough) AND the pole boarders keep hitting them as they drift downwind and out of site. I'm sure that the only thing windsurfers want wrap around their poles is a swedish stripper. maybe KBV and the schools need to take a some time to look out for newbies (their students or not) and help them out. Actually that goes for the rest of us too. an adopt a newbie aproach - (I'll take the swedish strippers)
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
26 Mar 2006 9:09pm
quote:
Originally posted by robecq

I'm almost sorry I started this thread, It was NOT meant to be a he said she said thread about f'ing leashes. The problem IS that people are losing their boards because they have chosen not to use a leash (fair enough) and can't or wont bodydrag upwind (not good enough) AND the pole boarders keep hitting them as they drift downwind and out of site. I'm sure that the only thing windsurfers want wrap around their poles is a swedish stripper. maybe KBV and the schools need to take a some time to look out for newbies (their students or not) and help them out. Actually that goes for the rest of us too. an adopt a newbie aproach - (I'll take the swedish strippers)




Bring on the Swedes...

OK... so ppl are loosing boards coz they can't, or won't, do one of two things. Is it that simple? Of course not! In combination with the other factors is "location" and "experience". StKilda isn't great for newbs that are getting up onto boards and riding! It's OK for newbs to the point of riding, at that point it is time to find another "location".

StKilda just isn't good for newb "riders"!

Of course others, esp' with vested interests, might disagree... and the choice of "metro-handy" locations is slim... but ppl at that level are not equiped for riding that far offshore in what is almost always choppy onshore conditions. Period!
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
27 Mar 2006 12:28am
Newbies will always be on beaches, it is us who can help them to get safe (see my previous post).
It is a matter of choice (again), and I've seen it so many times when more experienced kiters will give a hand to an newbie.

Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
27 Mar 2006 12:17am
quote:
Originally posted by silviu

quote:
Originally posted by Mr Plow

If you kite 5-7km out then you had better be a damn good swimmer.

That is possibly the most dumb, irresponsible move I have heard of.

Where is your support? What happens if your leading edge deflates/pops?

Yet another hero giving kiting a great rap....seriously mate - its not impressive, just mid numbingly stupid.


Mr Plow

I am kitesurfing ALWAYS with:
GPS.
Mobile phone.
Someone knows always where I am going, and when I do expect to come back
If possible in pair with somone else
And don't forget, I am doing this only in the Port Phillip Bay, so, if I cant go back... I always get to a safe shore from where I can be picked up.
Before going to the beach:
Check the latest forcast on Bureau of Meteorology website.
Check the Bay wind Website.
Check the sky!
I wear always:
Helmet
Long wetsuit
PFD/impact vest
Booties
Generaly:
Never jump near the beach
Keep a safe distance from stupids
I rather go 100 m downwind to land my kite, than to land it on a crowded beach
I am a good friend of the Life Saving Club
never kite on a beach I don't know, unless I am getting some advice from the locals.
And the list is longer and longer.
And by the way, yes I am a bloddy good swimmer, and I know very well most of the self rescue techniques.
So before judging, and insulting, get all the facts!!!



you forgot the kitchen sink
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:02pm
Good on ya silviu.....you do what you feel is right and stick to it, a man of conviction in your own special way.

It must be a buzz being out alone in the middle of Port Phillip Bay, certainly would beat buzzing back and forth in the froth around St. Kilda...and I bet the water is cleaner out there, and the view must be supurb! If I ever come to Melb. again, I'de love to go out there with you...crazy as that may seem.

However, I really do loath the place as I do not find much natural beauty there and feel that all Melbournites are Euro wanabees...sort of like Sydney people are NYC wanabees. I still can't understand how someone who is lucky enough to be able to live in this country would choose Melb.....beats me. There must be millions of good reasons though, but nobody's telling.
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:31pm
quote:
Originally posted by gruezi

Good on ya silviu.....you do what you feel is right and stick to it, a man of conviction in your own special way.

It must be a buzz being out alone in the middle of Port Phillip Bay, certainly would beat buzzing back and forth in the froth around St. Kilda...and I bet the water is cleaner out there, and the view must be supurb! If I ever come to Melb. again, I'de love to go out there with you...crazy as that may seem.

However, I really do loath the place as I do not find much natural beauty there and feel that all Melbournites are Euro wanabees...sort of like Sydney people are NYC wanabees. I still can't understand how someone who is lucky enough to be able to live in this country would choose Melb.....beats me. There must be millions of good reasons though, but nobody's telling.



I'm with him!

It's only saving grace is some of the people I've met. (OK... so most of them are from elsewhere too.)
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:32pm
Damn... I think they all are!!!
azza
azza
1338 posts
1338 posts
26 Mar 2006 10:45pm
OK gruezi, you win...

yes there is million$ of reasons, but none enough for me... this summer was nice though, lots of potential, but when it comes to reality "I'd much rather be elsewhere!" [and that's in no way reflective to those people I've kited with this season, rather a judgement on the place in general. If that upsets you then too bad; cities blow!]

Give me an open beach any day.
doppelganger
doppelganger
VIC
337 posts
VIC, 337 posts
27 Mar 2006 3:15am
quote:
you become airbourne with the board on your feet, be it from an intentional jump or from a nasty gust/loft

whilst airbourne, the board comes off your feet and lags behind you slightly. the leash does not get loaded but manages to keep the board roughly on your trajectory

you hit the water and stop.

the board cleans you up.




Thanks for the constructive imformation jan,
After some good rides today,I've decided not go for a leash.I'm starting to cut the board in and the speeds increasing.
I do wish I had had a leash during the first learning stages.All my spills during the learning stage's where the board came off were very minor and on one occassion the leash would have saved about an hour walk.My body dragging was ok,it was the drop in wind and tide that done me in,the time it took to get to the board,resulted in ending up in a sh$t wind area.
I personaly think that there are occassions when a board leash(with weak link) could be used.With the right instructor and correct student I think it would be a plus in the very early stages,AFTER you can body drag,self launch ect.

silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
27 Mar 2006 7:54am
quote:
Originally posted by gruezi

Good on ya silviu.....you do what you feel is right and stick to it, a man of conviction in your own special way.

It must be a buzz being out alone in the middle of Port Phillip Bay, certainly would beat buzzing back and forth in the froth around St. Kilda...and I bet the water is cleaner out there, and the view must be supurb! If I ever come to Melb. again, I'de love to go out there with you...crazy as that may seem.

However, I really do loath the place as I do not find much natural beauty there and feel that all Melbournites are Euro wanabees...sort of like Sydney people are NYC wanabees. I still can't understand how someone who is lucky enough to be able to live in this country would choose Melb.....beats me. There must be millions of good reasons though, but nobody's telling.



You will be welcome, and I really look forward to see you here, and show you "the view form the bay".
It is really superb, and as you gou out, the view is starting to "open", like watching through a "fish eye lens": the perspective is wide and beautyfull. And in several occasions I had dolphins "chasing" me.
Regarding the reasons someone will live in Melbourne... in three words: it's the best!!!
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
27 Mar 2006 7:58am
quote:
Originally posted by Spacemonkey!

quote:
Originally posted by silviu

quote:
Originally posted by Mr Plow

If you kite 5-7km out then you had better be a damn good swimmer.

That is possibly the most dumb, irresponsible move I have heard of.

Where is your support? What happens if your leading edge deflates/pops?

Yet another hero giving kiting a great rap....seriously mate - its not impressive, just mid numbingly stupid.



Mr Plow

I am kitesurfing ALWAYS with:
GPS.
Mobile phone.
Someone knows always where I am going, and when I do expect to come back
If possible in pair with somone else
And don't forget, I am doing this only in the Port Phillip Bay, so, if I cant go back... I always get to a safe shore from where I can be picked up.
Before going to the beach:
Check the latest forcast on Bureau of Meteorology website.
Check the Bay wind Website.
Check the sky!
I wear always:
Helmet
Long wetsuit
PFD/impact vest
Booties
Generaly:
Never jump near the beach
Keep a safe distance from stupids
I rather go 100 m downwind to land my kite, than to land it on a crowded beach
I am a good friend of the Life Saving Club
never kite on a beach I don't know, unless I am getting some advice from the locals.
And the list is longer and longer.
And by the way, yes I am a bloddy good swimmer, and I know very well most of the self rescue techniques.
So before judging, and insulting, get all the facts!!!



you forgot the kitchen sink



You will be amazed, I didn't: I have a "camel back" with me!![}:)]
Gru
Gru
SA
14 posts
Gru Gru
SA, 14 posts
27 Mar 2006 11:24am
If you are going to use a leash then go the Reel Leash.

Call me a blouse but I mainly use it so I can get going again quickly, I hate wasting the time dragging, especially as we have had a few people munched off our local by White pointers.

I have been using one for a couple of years and never had a rebound issue. I still wear a helmet though, mainly because the board is close to you and waves can knock it into you - which is perhaps the biggest risk I have found. I would never use a surfboard leash, a guy at my local use to use one...4 years ago he had an incident where the board recoiled into him and the fins sliced him up shockingly, huge lacerations to his neck and arm and was carted off by an ambulance.... Ironically he is now looking at Reel leash as he lost a thousand bucks worth of board a couple of weeks a go.

Re the breaking strain, the Reel leash clip is rated at 270 pounds, which still seems a little high and I would be interested in the cable tie option.
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
27 Mar 2006 9:34am
Ooooh ooh is this a nibble on gruezis line he's busy kiting - I better take it
quote:
Originally posted by silviu
Regarding the reasons someone will live in Melbourne... in three words: it's the best!!!


This topic always reminds me of that rego plate slogan "Victoria - on the move"
Always makes me think "Bloody good idea - why the hell would it want to stay there"
RAL INN
RAL INN
SA
2898 posts
SA, 2898 posts
27 Mar 2006 12:31pm
this thread has really gotten of track.

The original ? who is responsible for damage?
the owner of the Kiteboard.

Any excuse for useing a board leash will sound pretty lame in a coroners court.

And here I was thinking the real problem at St Kilda was gay/bow community.

Not that's there's anything wrong with that
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply