a poll on pasha at newcastle will it get off

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
brucex
brucex
QLD
701 posts
QLD, 701 posts
29 Jun 2007 2:21pm
Tell us if you think they will get this boat off the beach in 1 piece
Mr float
Mr float
NSW
3452 posts
NSW, 3452 posts
29 Jun 2007 2:42pm
yes
(or else)
jayoox
jayoox
NSW
16 posts
NSW, 16 posts
29 Jun 2007 5:48pm
No. They'll get it off, but piece by piece and year by year.
laurie
laurie
NSW
3904 posts
NSW, 3904 posts
29 Jun 2007 6:14pm
Seems to be working well as a tourist attraction - maybe they don't want to remove it!?
Juddy
Juddy
WA
1103 posts
WA, 1103 posts
29 Jun 2007 5:10pm
So nobody's kiting at Nobby's at the moment then?
Swinger
Swinger
NSW
59 posts
NSW, 59 posts
29 Jun 2007 7:58pm
ill get off befor it does
keep swinging
maramu
maramu
SA
28 posts
SA, 28 posts
29 Jun 2007 7:38pm
reckon it'd form some great banks for surfing, right and a left of each side
Blownaway
Blownaway
QLD
776 posts
QLD, 776 posts
29 Jun 2007 9:38pm
a few snatch straps an a land cruiser is all they need,i can hook the troopy up to her an put it in low an away we go
tobes
tobes
NSW
1000 posts
NSW, 1000 posts
29 Jun 2007 9:49pm
What about putting one of these babies up while the westerlies are blowing?
foxxaero.homestead.com/indsail_028.html
Might save a few million in supertugs and broken cables!
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
29 Jun 2007 8:35pm
I'm afraid the worst could unfortunately happen.
That is;
the ship breaking up and spewing an enormous oil spill that will devastate the natural environment.
The risk of that occurring could have been lessened by the removal of all the oil from the ship.
The task would have been challenging but not impossible.
It would have cost a lot of money but that is the price the ship owners need to bear,
to act in a responsible manner and to avoid environmental vandalism at any cost.
Baz
Baz
NSW
205 posts
Baz Baz
NSW, 205 posts
29 Jun 2007 11:09pm
Only the front half.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
29 Jun 2007 11:51pm
it aint gonna break up, it's sitting on a big bed of sand with a few reefy bits being pulverised by it's thick steel hull.

the question is: is the government going to take removing it seriously? or just watch a few tugs say, i think i can, i think i can!
choicey
choicey
QLD
280 posts
QLD, 280 posts
30 Jun 2007 11:40pm
slave, i reckon if ya take the oil out, the thing will implode and break up. crap situation for locals.

looks like a job 4 the gas axe.
Blaster
Blaster
WA
501 posts
WA, 501 posts
30 Jun 2007 10:23pm
OK seriously, is it sea worth after all this?? I think not!! When the weather settles they should pump off anything dangerous to the environment. Have some engineers survey and then get it reinforced where necessary.. Oxy torch the thing to death basically leaving a hull that with reinforcements in place won't collapse... Then pull the hull out. Tow it to god nows where in your little place on earth and do whatever.

Expensive, yes. Time consuming, yes. Any other option, NO.

Give the insurance company no option, just say this is what is going to happen and your paying.

So to answer your question I don't think so, but hope so for the local surfers, kiters and community.
Baz
Baz
NSW
205 posts
Baz Baz
NSW, 205 posts
1 Jul 2007 12:58am
Its going to break in half, spill some fuel, kill a gold fish or two, then get gas axed, and in six months time it will be Pasha Bulker who!
jquigley
jquigley
WA
205 posts
WA, 205 posts
1 Jul 2007 12:09am
I can't believe they haven't pumped any oil/fuel ashore by now if they're not confident of getting the ship off. Seeing the video of it bouncing around on the bottom the other night didn't look good.


As for the oil spill environmental damage - the long term effects of oil spills don't seem to be long lasting from what I've read. Though no consolation to the local marine critters/surfers/etc, oil isn't very toxic and breaks down pretty quickly in the overall scheme of things www.madsci.org/posts/archives/may99/926359264.Mi.r.html

J-P


dachopper
dachopper
WA
1802 posts
WA, 1802 posts
1 Jul 2007 10:55am
I don't think there is any way it is going to break up , it's a couple years old and has a few scraches on the bottom??? it hasn't been torpedo'd or hit an ice burg doing 40 kts, it just slowly ran aground like a dingy when you come into a beach on some rocks.

they have allready pumped oil into the safer tanks inside the ship so there's probably no chance of any spill even if it just sits there for months rubbing the bottom, cause its not rubbing near the tanks. They would send guys inside to patch the damage up anyway?

Too much over-reaction I think, if it were EVER going to leak it would have done it in the 40kt flood storm with huge seas that smashed it onto the reef in the first place..

waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
1 Jul 2007 6:55pm
quote:
Originally posted by jquigley
oil isn't very toxic and breaks down pretty quickly in the overall scheme of things






Hmmm....
Is 700 tons of fuel oil dumped on Nobbys Beach toxic enough for ya ?
That's what the ship is currently holding.
Plus another 100 tons of other toxic liquids.
Nice.
Quite a chemical cocktail.

While they repair and reconnect the tow-lines,
the window of opportunity is quickly closing.
It will be around another month before they get another go with the right tides (weather permitting).
It's costing the company $300,000 per day in salvage work.
Strongbow
Strongbow
WA
273 posts
WA, 273 posts
1 Jul 2007 7:39pm
I always knew they would get it floating again.
Na I thought it would be heading back to Korea as scrap metal, but no it is mooving.
jquigley
jquigley
WA
205 posts
WA, 205 posts
1 Jul 2007 9:04pm
Hey Waveslave,

I thought I put what I said about oil spills in context of not being a good thing and why wouldn't they take every precaution to avoid it, ie, pump the oil off the ship?

Oil is something that occurs in the natural environment and mother nature does have a way of dealing with it. I thought this was interesting and whether you like it or not it's a fact. You selectively quoted me so readers could take my comments out of context. You didn't even qoute the full sentence.






Blaster
Blaster
WA
501 posts
WA, 501 posts
1 Jul 2007 10:05pm
Keep the updates coming...I'm on dialup for a week whilst my server sends out a new modem. CW won't stream like broadband does for me unfortunately. Must be a relief for all those involved tyo see it moving...

I told ya so[}:)]
Strongbow
Strongbow
WA
273 posts
WA, 273 posts
1 Jul 2007 10:25pm
quote:
[i] Must be a relief for all those involved tyo see it moving...

I told ya so[}:)]



Except for those in the tourist industry. [}:)]

Oh yeh, the front of superstructure is nearly paralell to the cam now, so it has turned more than 90 deg now. Looking good.
angie pangi
angie pangi
QLD
1782 posts
QLD, 1782 posts
2 Jul 2007 8:05am
Just heard on sunrise news program this morning that they are trying to contain a small oil leak they have discovered after moving the ship more then 90 degrees last night.

Lets hope it doesnt turn into anything major!!

Angie xx
pearl
pearl
NSW
984 posts
NSW, 984 posts
2 Jul 2007 8:48am

quote[As for the oil spill environmental damage - the long term effects of oil spills don't seem to be long lasting from what I've read. Though no consolation to the local marine critters/surfers/etc, oil isn't very toxic and breaks down pretty quickly in the overall scheme of things www.madsci.org/posts/archives/may99/926359264.Mi.r.html

J-P]quote




Looks like all who said to pump the oil off have been proved correct. As for mr Brabbans findings (he was probably given a 'grant' by the oil companies to do a study) oil is a bitch when it washes ashore, no matter how many "oil eating bacteria" are residing on Nobbies beach. We have had numerous minor spills (or dumps) over the years on the north coast nsw. It stays on the headlands and rocks for ages and ends up on your feet and board. Its not easy to remove and requires a solvent more often than soap. It certainly isn't any exon valdez, so hopefully they can contain any leaks.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
2 Jul 2007 10:00am
quote:
Originally posted by jquigley

Hey Waveslave,

I thought I put what I said about oil spills in context of not being a good thing and why wouldn't they take every precaution to avoid it, ie, pump the oil off the ship?

Oil is something that occurs in the natural environment and mother nature does have a way of dealing with it. I thought this was interesting and whether you like it or not it's a fact. You selectively quoted me so readers could take my comments out of context. You didn't even qoute the full sentence.










Jquigley,
Sorry for the misunderstanding...
but I was confused by your fence-sitting.

On one hand you say pump out the oil...
and then on the other hand you say;
well,if the oil spills that's ok too...
The bacteria will fix it.
lol.

I just don't think it's ok to turn the environment into a sewer,
especially if there was a good chance to avoid the problem in the first place.

But really it's just about the money...
it's always about the money.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
2 Jul 2007 11:06am
quote:
Originally posted by Mr float

Its almost gone
http://www.coastalwatch.com/camera/NobbysBeach.htm



It's almost gone, hey ?
That's an ambiguous post, dude.
By the way, your username is particularly suitable for this topic, Mr Float.
lol.

Well,
the post could mean that it's gone back out to sea....
Or it could mean that it's gone bad, a lost cause.
Let's hope that the former is the correct prediction.

But according to the cam, it's only gone 90 degrees.
90 to go.
But you always have to factor in lady luck with stuff like this.
And how lucky were the salvage crews in scoring calm, offshore weather conditions to coincide with the kingtide ?
Super lucky.
But it's never over till the fat lady sings.
jquigley
jquigley
WA
205 posts
WA, 205 posts
2 Jul 2007 2:34pm
Yeh, ok I guess it did sound a bit rich, sorry if you thought I was advocating we have a 700 tonne oil spill.

Thanks for the apology by the way, my nose is still bleeding but thanks.

As for my comment on oil not being very toxic: I worked as a fitter for 15 years and had the occasional oil bath, hydraulic hose burst in front of me, etc and I can say it's not a pleasant experience but you can get covered in the stuff, get it in your eyes even swallow it without any real adverse effects. It's not toxic in the sense that it causes a chemical reaction and shuts down your nervous system or something akin to cyanide or arsenic. But obviously wreaks havoc on the environment because of it's physical properties ie, sticks like the proverbial to a blanket, renders birds feathers unflyable fishes gills unbreathable, etc.

As for it all being about the money, I agree.

Somehow in this day and age where it seems we have to pay for just about everything we do, we can still go out and enjoy being on the mostly pristine ocean and have a priceless experience with no money changing hands, allelujiah!! If the government gave the EPA the power to fine oil spillers let's say ooooh a million bucks for every tonne of oil spilt there might be a few less accidents.

Anyway that's just a few more of my fence sitting thoughts. Better get back to work.

Go the microbes.

J-P

J-P

Cabron
Cabron
QLD
363 posts
QLD, 363 posts
2 Jul 2007 10:53pm
Going, going, gone....very cool watching it move quite quickly off the vision of the beachcam @ nobby's.
Hopefully it doesn't dump it's load, now out at sea

user
user
WA
1140 posts
WA, 1140 posts
3 Jul 2007 6:09am
I believe the oil on board is in the form of the fuel that the ship uses. It is relatively safe in the tanks.

It is not an oil tanker. It is empty,on its way to pick up coal.
Mr float
Mr float
NSW
3452 posts
NSW, 3452 posts
3 Jul 2007 9:57am
I wonder where the bit of rudder is that broke off ? Hopefully not firmly embedded in the reef.A hazard to surfers,kitesurfers ,windsurfers .Apparently the reef has been badly damaged and the break has gone.
kitebored
kitebored
NSW
593 posts
NSW, 593 posts
3 Jul 2007 1:04pm
yeh, it'll be interesting to see how things have changed there.. maybe we'll get some good banks over the coming weeks as the sand around the reef moves around.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply