Good advice by others.
I would add:
[1] I love small SUPs, and especially short ones, but they are worth it only in small glassy waves. Any bump or chop and they become hell fast.
[2] As I age (I am "only" 65yo), length becomes also critical for ease of "pop up" (actually standing up). The sweet spot to stand on becomes critically small under 8', and the stiffer you are, the harder it is to land your feet there. I was using 6'8" SUPs at 97kg without problems, but after 63yo I realized I needed 8' to not fall when standing up. We are all age differently... but we all age :-)
[3] Volume by itself does mean nothing, always compare the board volume to the rider weight (ideally the total weight: rider+board+paddle+wetsuit...). A good ratio is the simple "guild factor" (GF): Board volume in liters / rider weight. This means:
- Your spice: 106 / 67 = 1.58 GF
- Your planned custom: 95/67 = 1.42 GF
- Your goal: 85/67 = 1.27 GF
[3] On volume, I just stumbled yesterday on two interesting videos of two people SUPing in the same kind of conditions (bumpy Hawaiian surf).
The young pro (Zane) is at a GF of 0.94
The very good, but non-pro older Wayde is at GF 1.34
Of course, on gentler and cleaner surf, you can comfortably get to lowers GF, but you do not need ultra-small GFs to rip.