Is Speed sailing Better than Wavesailing?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4170 posts
WA, 4170 posts
8 Mar 2007 10:34pm
The GPS-speedsurfing method takes a bit of getting your head around, I got it wrong the first time I posted. The primary ranking used on the site is the 5 by 10 second average. The gps software - easily available on the net - will look for your 5 best 10 second runs in a day and take the average. You can only get one run counted on each reach. There's a little bit of uncertainty in GPS speeds calculated over short times or distances so this method was decided on, after much thought by the organisers, as a reasonably accurate method to compare sailors.

Mostly though, in casual comparisons on the beach we talk in GPS max, the value you get on the max speed field on your GPS display. It uses doppler shift rather than the location information. Location is stored at 2 second intervals in memory for downloading later. GPS display max is considered to be more accurate than a single 2 sec reading which is obtained from the down load . But seeing the display max relies on the sailors memory and eyesight the primary ranking is based on the tracks which are saved to be verified by the timekeepers. On very rare occasions the gps max can be out but it is usually obvious and the tracks won't add up when you download.

The timekeepers always ask for your tracks when you do a pb in any of the categories.

The other categories are just taken the single best for the day.
2 sec max ( usually optimistic by a knot or so compared to the display max)
100m
250m ( should be accurate to plus or minus 1/2 a knot )
500m (so you can compare to official records set over timed 500m courses)

Nautical mile (about 1830 m (?)), a good distance to have a crack at, best if you can do it without a gybe, takes exactly 2 mins if you can average 30 knots, not easy, not many flat water courses that long so chop is involved and the playing fields are levelled. There was a state vs state competition for the month of february over this distance which generated some good competition. An over 30 knot average for one member on the winning SA team. The gps is quite accurate over this distance)

One hour. There's a 1 hr state vs state comp going on at the moment - for the month of march. WA is leading I think. If we plane for 20 mins in the hr in Canberra it's a good day.

But GPS's are good value, only $250, they certainly add another dimension and challenge to your sailing. You'll end up going way off the wind as you try for better times, ie. it discourages BAFing, so as well as getting faster you'll also get better at coming back upwind.
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
9 Mar 2007 12:39am
Well,

Lots of chat on this topic.

here is my 2 bobs worth!!

Most sailors think they are absolutely honking (33+ knots) and in reality they are doing 27 knots at best. 27 knots in chop/waves feels seriously fast.

Most people sail too "square" to the wind to go really fast. - It takes some serious guts to bear off to 120 degrees+ to get top speeds - regardless of water/wave condition to get some top speeds. Most people do not carry enough sail are to get good top speeds. Mal Wright is carrying a 5.0 in conditions most people would carry a 3.5. The flat water at a Sandy Point helps as the rig does not 'jerk around' due to chop as much - allowing you to carry more sail. At Sandy Point I have sailed a 5.7 in 30-43 knots, I could not hold this sail in choppy conditions elsewhere - so there is an advantage.

35 knots is very fast and you have very little time to react to a 'spinout' situation - as I have found from personal experience at Sandy Point. - Ian Knight is right - a few metres off the the bank is close to suicide at Sandy Point; and Ian by the way that comment "did ya get that -Yeahhhhhhh" when videoing my monumental stack at 36 knots is spot on!!

see. http://50knots.xs4all.nl/gps-speedsurfing/media/events/Al%20Greens%20Sandy%20Point%20Speed%20Fortnight/05-10-06/index2.html


Watch the speed runs video for big stack towards the end.

To summarise a 5x10sec >30 knots is impressive in normal conditions.

In Brisbane my 5 x 10 is currently within 1.5 knots of speeds attained at Sandy Point - so local speed is possible - but you have to work a lot harder.

As to the original topic of this forum - I love both forms of the sport, but as I get older and the opportunity to get into the surf dimishes I tend to favour speed.


- J
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4170 posts
WA, 4170 posts
9 Mar 2007 12:02am
Yeh sorry mate, glad you popped up OK but I did learn from your stack before I ventured out. What was he doing that was different to every one else? Ah 15 metres from the bank -don't go there too choppy. It's a fine line to follow. Sandy point counts as "real world conditions' I think.
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 8:25am
My opinion on posting GPS speed on this site is KISS, therefore I suggest either a peak GPS display, or 2 sec peak. Remember this site is more about fun, and not to be taken tooooo seriously!!!. For those who are serious about GPS and speed, use the GPS-Speedsurfing.com site, and post proper data logs there.
sick_em_rex
sick_em_rex
NSW
1601 posts
NSW, 1601 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:13am
My first use of a GPS (Foretrex 101) netted me a peak 2 second average of 31.9 knots. All I know is I was faster than Fred Haywood so I was wrapt!
I weight 75kg, was using a Fanatic Ultra Hawk volume 96 litres and a Simmer Onshore wave 5.7. I think the wind would have been around 20-25knots but honestly who really knows.
That was last year and since then I haven't been able to better it. It really is about the consistency of the wind and the piece of water you're sailing. I sailed Port Stephens over Xmas and found a super flat section of water behind a mid port sandbank and was doing consistent 29-30 knot averages but the wind wasn't as strong.
I also sailed from Kyeemagh down to Dolls Point in a south easter a month or so ago and did a 22knot average over a 4 km distance.
Hardie, like the exact reason you started this thread, speedsailing really is a drug now and I just wanna go faster and faster......
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
9 Mar 2007 9:16am
I'm with you Hardie, KISS

But all the info posted so far has been both helpful & interesting

Thanks
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:38am
quote:
Originally posted by sick_em_rex

My first use of a GPS (Foretrex 101) netted me a peak 2 second average of 31.9 knots. All I know is I was faster than Fred Haywood so I was wrapt!


Fred did his speed over 500m not 2 seconds, there is a good couple of knots difference (at least) between 2 second peak and 500m.

My only gripe with GPS's (and it's not aimed at anyone) is keep it real, compare apples with apples ie a 40 knot peak is not 40 knots over 500m that the pro's have done.
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 10:38am
quote:
Originally posted by firiebob

I'm with you Hardie, KISS





A coupla things then.

Why don't people vote here for 2 sec peak versus GPS display peak and that's what we use to discuss our speed sessions, on an ongoing thread titled "GPS Speed Sessions". I'll start one today as we have a rip roaring seabreeze today

Another option: For the people that want something more serious on this site, then we could ask "Laurie" to set something up, that is a bit more formal, maybe top speeds of the day or week, and a top 10 or top 5 per calender year as on GPS-Speedsurfing.com?
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
9 Mar 2007 12:40pm
Gotta agree with Hardie. If you really want to get into it the GPS site is for you. You will definitely find some very in depth and deep stuff there.
Harrow, everyone should be using the 2 sec bit as thats what is recommended on GPS.
Firiebob, I am so jealous of that Green island pic. It looks unreal.
GPS units arent just for the pro's. I use mine to log distance, time on water, max speed obvious!!! and i keep a Word document with all that and also the conditions, gear used and who I sailed with.
Its all fun
Wineman
Wineman
NSW
1412 posts
NSW, 1412 posts
9 Mar 2007 1:32pm
quote:
Originally posted by bubs
What about age? thats got to be a factor . Don't know how to work it out though. Leave that to the experts but i think it should be there.

Bubs



YEAH.
For every year below 50 - minus 1%
For every year below 21 - additional minus 2%[}:)][}:)][}:)]

You are really goin' to have to go fast, aren't ya

NOW GET BACK TO STUDY
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
9 Mar 2007 12:37pm
keep it as gps display, that way it keeps people with navman etc units involved. There is no checking of results anyway so it dosent really matter.
slowboat
slowboat
WA
560 posts
WA, 560 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:50am
After using GPS for a couple of years, and analysing the tracks most times...

*Spikes are common- especially when you fall in
*Often they are in the believable speed range
*The display speed is a filtered (average over 3 or 4 secs)speed based on doppler measurement- which is accurate until the signal drops out (or the GPS is in a "guessing" mode). Often my max display speed does not correlate with the track log at all (can be out by several knots). But there is then usually an obvious spike in the track log at about the same time.
*2 second peak speeds derived from your track log when you download it onto the computer can be very inaccurate. ie +-2 knots or more, but usually +- 0.5 of a knot
*Some GPS units store more information than others, and can resolve shorter peaks a lot better (eg naviGPS)

Having a NaviGPS and also a Foretrex, and seeing the comparison some other guys did between multiple units worn at the same time shows that the Navi can consistently and repeatedly resolve speeds to 0.2kt every second. The Garmin Foretrex in the same mode gives more like +- 2 knots between units.

So... for a fun ladder I'd suggest the max display speed if you dont want to do downloads. But... the best speeds will quite possibly be the most believable spikes.

For an easy piece of GPS analysis software, check out realspeed. Its Mal Wright's baby, and can be downloaded from www.intellimass.com

Its relatively easy to use. Best features- it can dowload off the GPS, can process doppler speed info if your GPS supports it (ie NaviGPS with SD card installed), IT AUTOMATICALLY DETECTS SPIKES and removes them from the result processing. I think you have to register it...

Tips for minimising spikes:
1) Dont dunk the gps for long when you stack it
2) Keep the GPS on your arm or somewhere directly exposed to the sky
3) DO NOT put it under your wetsuit. The salt water kills the satellite signals and makes your track a spikefest as the GPS has to do a lot of guessing.

have fun...
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 12:06pm
Slowboat knows what he is talking about, so for the purposes of this site let's use the GPS Display peak speed.

Though he should be banned from posting/competing

My sponsor Windwarrior have a comp and has agreed to put up a prize.

The comp goes something like this they will put up details soon.

On the Windwarrior.com site they will have a register of speeds, and given I'm theeir overweight speedsailor, I will represent them. I will post my fastest GPS Display speed, and Whoever has the highest GPS Dispaly that is faster than mine, during the period of the contest wins the prize, or I get to keep it

The windwarrior site is not intending to compete with Seabreeze, they won't be having a forum or any discussions. Just a promotional fun competition.
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
9 Mar 2007 2:43pm
Well done Hardie!!!!!!
Thats excellent news, pity its at the end of the season. I doubt we are going to get any decent wind for awhile now especially forr us weekend sailors. I think I will have to have a PD day soon
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
9 Mar 2007 2:08pm
WOW Hardie, just checked your latest GPS speed post, you're right up there straight up
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 2:27pm
quote:
Originally posted by firiebob

WOW Hardie, just checked your latest GPS speed post, you're right up there straight up



It's fantastic conditions here today, just did a quick 30 min session, had to test some fins for weed, and plus my adrenalin has been pumping since 4am this morning, I was gonna be a ****** mess if I didn't use some of it up.

Really understood what a difference fins make today, 59.6 on a weed fin (6 runs), 63.5 on a custom speed fin (2 runs).

Wanna save meself for this arvies session
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
9 Mar 2007 3:43pm
Can we keep it in knots please, we aren't driving cars here.
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
9 Mar 2007 5:53pm
Now Im really desperate for some wind, need a fix!!!!!
Wineman
Wineman
NSW
1412 posts
NSW, 1412 posts
9 Mar 2007 7:46pm
quote:
Originally posted by ka43

Now Im really desperate for some wind, need a fix!!!!!



Yeah. how about WA send over some green arrows.
You've got too many
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
9 Mar 2007 6:07pm
Yeh, swap you some rain for wind
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 9:33pm
Yes we were very lucky today, hope to see some really fast times posted.

Got really sorted out in the afternoon session, much windier and choppier, lost my confidence intially couldn't get near my speeds of the morning session. have to thank Elmo for his encouragement and help, without which I would not have eventually gone faster, probably the longest run at such speed. Elmo had bad luck with spin out problems, which toatlly destroys your confidence at those speeds in chop. Thanx again Elmo, you'll get me next time
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:28pm
quote:
Originally posted by Wineman

quote:
Originally posted by bubs
What about age? thats got to be a factor . Don't know how to work it out though. Leave that to the experts but i think it should be there.

Bubs



YEAH.
For every year below 50 - minus 1%
For every year below 21 - additional minus 2%[}:)][}:)][}:)]

You are really goin' to have to go fast, aren't ya

NOW GET BACK TO STUDY



Ha thats so tight lol. Under 16 should be + 10. I don't have homework over the long weekend . Taken advantage of this and going windsurfing on Sunday.

That age thing HAS to be modified lol.

Bubs
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
9 Mar 2007 10:54pm
Whats a GPS?
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:01pm
quote:
Originally posted by Greenroom

Whats a GPS?



Greenroom's Pole Surfer
Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:10pm
I was gonna stay out of it but during today's sesh I was thinking to myself:

how could speed sailing come close to charging down the line on a head-high wave, in 25knots+, spotting the curling lip and lining it up...


I even managed to Elmo my face!

speed sailing's just not wave sailing.
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:15pm
quote:
Originally posted by Leech

I was gonna stay out of it but during today's sesh I was thinking to myself:

how could speed sailing come close to charging down the line on a head-high wave, in 25knots+, spotting the curling lip and lining it up...


I even managed to Elmo my face!

speed sailing's just not wave sailing.



used to feel the same way myself, came and checked you guys out, if you were sailing with greeny, and definitely looked fun, stirred me to think "Will I go and have my 3rd speed sail of the day..... Yeh I've had enough, might join the boys?........ Nah just one more speed session, need that speed adrenalin fix.......
Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:19pm
quote:
Originally posted by hardie

quote:
Originally posted by Leech

I was gonna stay out of it but during today's sesh I was thinking to myself:

how could speed sailing come close to charging down the line on a head-high wave, in 25knots+, spotting the curling lip and lining it up...


I even managed to Elmo my face!

speed sailing's just not wave sailing.



used to feel the same way myself, came and checked you guys out, if you were sailing with greeny, and definitely looked fun, stirred me to think "Will I go and have my 3rd speed sail of the day..... Yeh I've had enough, might join the boys?........ Nah just one more speed session, need that speed adrenalin fix.......



yeah, i was there. i nearly overdosed on adrenalin. greenroom did

bit of a trek for you to not sail, isn't it?
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:23pm
quote:
Originally posted by Leech


yeah, i was there. i nearly overdosed on adrenalin. greenroom did

bit of a trek for you to not sail, isn't it?




I live 500m from where you guys were sailing, I can see you sailing from upstairs (Bit spoilt, know I can sail it anytime, whereas the high winds for speed records don't often eventuate)........ Came and had a look and was debating whether to come out and join, or go home and get some more speed gear, speed gear won out
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:25pm
Im still shaking from the rush
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
9 Mar 2007 11:28pm
Sorry Hardie we were not where you think we were.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply