Volvo Ocean Race - Rule breach applications rejected

7:14 AM Mon 24 Oct 2011 GMT

'Volvo Ocean Race 2011-12' Chris Cameron/Camper 2011-12

Volvo Ocean Race 2011-12 - Two formal submissions by teams competing in the race, claiming that the race organisers had breached protocol by changing one of the strict Volvo Open 70 measurement rules, have been dismissed by an independent arbitration panel. Two applications were made to the arbitration panel claiming the Volvo Open 70 Rule Interpretation Group (VIG) had, in interpreting a class rule, changed that rule, something that is not permitted by the class rules and the Volvo Ocean Race Notice of Race.

The first application, made jointly by Abu Dhabi Ocean Racing and Puma Ocean Racing powered by BERG on October 11, was followed up the next day by a near-identical submission from Team Telef?nica.

The applications related to a specific ruling by the Volvo Interpretation Group (VIG) - the panel of experts responsible for providing official clarification on the precise meaning of measurement rules.

Specifically, the three teams believed that the VIG had overstepped its jurisdiction by interpreting Volvo Open 70 Class rule 10.1.9, in such a way as to change another rule, 10.1.6, which outlaws the use of any kind of adjustable standing rigging on the yachts.

At the heart of the collective application is believed to be the forestay system employed on the Camper with Emirates Team New Zealand boat, which the Abu Dhabi, Puma and Telef?nica purported is adjustable and could give Camper an unfair advantage during the 39,000 nautical mile race around the world.

The independent arbitration panel was chaired by British ISAF International Judge and arbitration specialist, Bryan Willis, who called on Australia's David Tillet, an ISAF International Judge and Chairman of the ISAF Racing Rules Committee, along with Brian McKenzie a barrister at law and solicitor from New Zealand, to help him make a ruling.

Before deliberating on the matter, the expert team requested written submissions from all interested parties. Input was subsequently provided by Puma, Groupama sailing team and the VIG chairman Andy Claughton. A response from Camper by Emirates Team New Zealand rules advisor Russell Green included a statement by co-skipper Stuart Bannatyne. No oral hearing took place.

The official decision of the panel released today stated: 'The AP is not satisfied that the VIG acted outside its jurisdiction in giving its interpretations, or that they have changed any Rule. The Applications are therefore dismissed.'

Volvo Ocean Race website

by Volvo Ocean Race

Newsfeed supplied by

#News #Sailing

Sailing

VHF Radio on the Water: Channels and Calls

Sailing

Reefing Early: Shorten Sail Before It's Too Late

Sailing

Reefing Early: Shorten Sail Before You Must

Sailing

Reefing: Read the Signs, Act Early

Sailing

Heaving To: Park the Boat in a Blow

Sailing

The Figure-8: Return to a Person Overboard

Sailing

Overnight at Anchor: Setting Up Right

Nearby
North Head, NSW	16 kn S
Little Bay, NSW	16 kn S
Cronulla, NSW	19 kn SSW
Windiest in Australia
Wattamolla, NSW	31 kn S
Most Windless in Australia
Mount Stuart (Defence), QLD	Calm	28°
Hottest in Australia
Victoria River Downs, NT	2 kn NNE	33°
Coldest in Australia
Mount Wellington, TAS	Calm	-1°
Wettest in Australia
Texas, QLD	11.0 mm

Volvo Ocean Race - Rule breach applications rejected

Read the Wind: Judge Its Force Without a Gauge

Heave-To: Sailing's Emergency Pause Button

The Beaufort Scale: How We Learned to Rank Wind

Live Weather

Nearby

Windiest in Australia

Most Windless in Australia

Hottest in Australia

Coldest in Australia

Wettest in Australia

Sailing Articles

Buy & Sell

2023 Ozone Alpha V2

2025 Duotone Rebel D/Lab

2025 VAYU Aura 111

2024 North Sonar 1500R Front Wing.

2024 Duotone Sky Style Sls

2023 Flysurfer Vmg

2024 Patrik Slalom 130

Know before you go

Download the Seabreeze app for iOS or Android.

Weather

Activities

About

Other

Support